Skip to content

By Colin Harding on

How to spot a collodion positive, also known as an ambrotype (early 1850s–1880s)

In this week's post about dating your photographs, Colin Harding shows you how to identify a collodion positive, also known as an ambrotype, using just a few simple clues.

Last week I began a series of posts showing you how to date your old family photographs using format and process, by looking at daguerreotypes, the very first commercial photographic process.

Boy wearing a top hat, c. 1858, J. Hickling, National Media Museum Collection
Boy wearing a top hat, c. 1858, J. Hickling, Science Museum Group collection

This week I’m going to show you how to identify a collodion positive—also known as an ambrotype—using just a few simple clues, then we’ll take a look at some examples of collodion positives in our collection.


About the collodion positive process

Collodion positives first appeared in about 1853. By the 1860s the process had largely disappeared from high street studios, but it remained popular with itinerant open-air photographers until the 1880s, because portraits could be made in a few minutes while sitters waited.

The collodion positive process, which was based on the collodion negative process invented by Frederick Scott Archer, reversed a negative image by bleaching the silver salts. The dark areas which would normally form the highlights in a printed image turned pale, and the clear areas which would form the shadows in the print appeared to be dark.

When presented against a black background, the dark areas of the original negative, which had been bleached with nitric acid or bichloride of mercury, appeared as highlights. The black backing, visible through the clear areas of the plate that originally formed the highlights, appeared as shadows.

Although the so-called collodion positive was in fact a negative, the emulsions were too thin to make satisfactory prints on paper. When the collodion positive was held to the light without the backing material, the image still looked like a negative, though paler than the standard required to make a satisfactory positive print.

The dark backing material could be a velvet pad held inside a presentation case, or a simple coating of black varnish for those made in lower-class studios and temporary booths erected at holiday resorts.

Beach photographers, c. 1885, National Media Museum Collection
Beach photographers, c. 1885, Science Museum Group collection

One slight drawback with the collodion process was that the image was reversed laterally, like the reflection you see in a mirror.

To correct this, the plate could be blackened on the collodion side or presented in the case emulsion-side down, which had the added benefit of protecting the vulnerable collodion layer. Otherwise, the surface of the finished plate was coated with clear varnish and it was protected under a ‘cover-glass’.


Why are collodion positives also known as ambrotypes?

Most people call collodion positives ‘ambrotypes’, which is technically incorrect.

The ambrotype process (patented by an American photographer, James Ambrose Cutting in 1854) was a particular variant of the process which used Canada balsam to seal the collodion plate to the cover glass. These are most commonly found in America.


Use these clues to identify a collodion positive

Case
Collodion positives are often confused with daguerreotypes because they are a similar size and were also usually supplied in a protective case or frame.

Portrait of a young girl and portrait of a woman, c. 1860, The Royal Photographic Society Collection, National Media Museum
Portrait of a young girl and portrait of a woman, c. 1860 © The Royal Photographic Society Collection

Glass negative
They were made by taking a glass negative and backing it with black cloth, paint, or varnish to produce a positive image.

Image
Unlike daguerreotypes, collodion positives always appear as a positive image, whatever angle you view them.

Quality
Collodion positives were much cheaper than daguerreotypes. The quality of the materials used to make their cases usually reflects this – compressed paper and card rather than leather and silk.


Examples of collodion positives in our collection

Babbitt's view of Niagra, c. 1860, Platt D. Babbitt, National Media Museum Collection
Babbitt’s view of Niagra, c. 1860, Platt D. Babbitt, Science Museum Group collection

Platt D. Babbitt set up a pavilion in front of Point View, later Prospect Point, on the American side of Niagara Falls. From here he photographed tourists taking in the view, without their knowledge, from the 1850s to the 1870s. He would then offer the photographs for sale, providing a lucrative business for himself and giving tourists a chance to own a souvenir of their trip.

Baker's boy, c. 1860, National Media Museum Collection
Baker’s boy, c. 1860, Science Museum Group collection

The sign on the cart reads: ‘Hygienic Bakery, Confectioners Co. Ltd. 7 High Rd., Willesden’. The photograph is mounted in an inexpensive papier-mâché case which was designed to hang on a wall. The subject-matter, the ready-made metal mount and style of case suggest that image was taken by an itinerant or non-studio-based photographer.

Family group, c. 1860, National Media Museum Collection
Family group, c. 1860, Science Museum Group collection

The entire family appear to be rather bewildered by the process of having their photograph taken. All retain their pose, with the exception of the baby on her mother’s lap who has moved and becomes a blurry, ghost-like figure.

Officer, c. 1860, National Media Museum Collection
Officer, c. 1860, Science Museum Group collection

This British cavalry soldier is wearing a short, tight fitting shell jacket and cap, carrying his sword and gloves in his hands. He had probably served in the British army during the Crimean War (1854–1856). This photograph has been hand-coloured to give a realistic colour to the officer’s uniform and to pick out the gold embroidery, sash and ring that he wears. Having an ambrotype hand-coloured cost extra.

Group of young boys, c. 1860, The Royal Photographic Society Collection, National Media Museum
Group of young boys, c. 1860 © The Royal Photographic Society Collection
Portrait of a young woman, c. 1860, National Media Museum Collection
Portrait of a young woman, c. 1860, Science Museum Group collection

The woman rests her elbow on a table, her arm next to an elegant vase of flowers and a cased photograph. The photograph on the table appears to be either an ambrotype or a daguerreotype. It may have been included to represent someone who had recently died.

Three friends, c. 1860, National Media Museum Collection
Three friends, c. 1860, Science Museum Group collection

These smartly-dressed, serious looking men are pictured in front of a painted background of a grand fireplace. They are all in suits and have flowers in their buttonholes, perhaps indicating this was taken on a special occasion.

Family in a boat, c. 1865, National Media Museum Collection
Family in a boat, c. 1865, Science Museum Group collection

Next week I’ll show you how to identify ferrotypes (1855 – c.1940s), also known—less accurately—as tintypes.

13 comments on “How to spot a collodion positive, also known as an ambrotype (early 1850s–1880s)

  1. I have a set of early photographs of Niagara Falls, taken probably in the mid to late 1800s. They are half plate and are positives on glass. It seems that two sheets of glass are sandwiched together and the image is therefore protected. These are positive images, not negative, and are transparent. I have been unable to find anything out about this type of photograph. Could these be a form of ambrotype, perhaps made by using the original as a negative and making a contact print onto another sheet of glass?

  2. I have a large collection of photographs on glass and am not sure exactly what they are and do not know of anywhere I could take them for assessment – I am in SW Scotland if you know of anywhere that might be willing to have a look and provide further information I would greatly apprectiate it.

  3. I have some pieces of the building by the Milken brothers new york in 1910 during the Porfiriato in the city of mexico what could be the greatest work of latinoamerica these collodion negatives could help me figure out the price and if someone interested in these beautiful pictures collection thanks

  4. I have just discovered three copper plates with images of people, presumably relatives, impregnated onto the copper. You have to tilt the plates in a particular direction to view the images, and these were almost sent for metal recycling. I would love to know if they were photograph plates but am not sure where to start enquiring.

  5. Hi there – I’m not sure if you still use this thread but I thought it was worth a shot. I have recently discovered (what appears to be) an Ambrotype photograph whilst looking through old photos from my Grandfather. Would you be able to help identify if this is, in fact, an Ambrotype and if it is a British or American photo? The clothing the woman is wearing bears a real resemblance to the American attire of that period, although I have got that wrong.

    Many thanks,
    Lizzy

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *